[The Phelps who fought with police that day and the Phelps seen otherwise] are two completely different people, … behavior won’t happen again.

He was being beaten. He paid a price for this.

You are supposed to infer beyond a reasonable doubt this man in his mind was going to kill Madden.

I learned a quick lesson: There’s no substitute for your own research.

were not seen by paramedics.

Our task is trying to beat a benchmark. In order to do that, we have to deviate from a benchmark in some way. But you also have to be mindful of the extent of risk...